Quick Answer
Buy the Mac mini M2 ($897.99) if you already own a monitor, keyboard, and mouse — it's the cheapest way into a modern Apple-silicon desktop, and you can plug it into the screen you already have. Buy the iMac 24" M1 ($749) if you want a beautiful, cable-free, all-in-one that works the moment you unbox it — a color-matched 4.5K screen, keyboard, and mouse in one clean package. Same Apple silicon inside; the real decision is "do I have a monitor, or do I want everything in one box?"
The One Question That Decides It
Both machines run the exact same M-series chips and the exact same macOS. The performance difference for everyday work — email, web, Office, photos, light video — is negligible. So don't agonize over benchmarks. The decision comes down to a single practical question:
Do you already have a monitor you're happy with?
- Yes, I have a good monitor → Mac mini. Don't pay for a second screen you don't need. Plug the mini into what you own and pocket the savings.
- No, or I want it to look great on the desk → iMac. The built-in 4.5K Retina display is genuinely excellent, and there are no cables, no dongles, and nothing to match — it's one clean object.
Mac mini — The Bring-Your-Own-Monitor Value Play
Mac mini M2 (2023) — $897.99
The mini is a 7.7-inch aluminum square that hides under a monitor or tucks behind it. It has the same M2 chip as a MacBook Air, so it flies through everyday work, and it stays cool and silent. The catch — and the whole point — is that it ships as just the computer: no screen, no keyboard, no mouse. If you already own those, that's a feature, not a flaw. You're not paying for a display you'd otherwise throw in a drawer.
- ✓ $897.99 — the lowest-cost entry into a modern Apple-silicon desktop
- ✓ Reuse the monitor, keyboard, and mouse you already own
- ✓ Two Thunderbolt ports, HDMI, USB-A, and Ethernet — drives up to two external displays
- ✓ Tiny, silent, and easy to hide on any desk
- ✗ You must supply your own screen, keyboard, and mouse
Mac mini M2 Pro (2023) — $999
Step up to the M2 Pro if you edit longer videos, compile code, run virtual machines, or push two big 4K/5K displays. It adds more CPU and GPU cores and more Thunderbolt ports. For web, Office, and photos it's overkill — buy it only if you have a genuinely heavy workload.
iMac — The All-in-One You Just Unbox and Use
iMac 24" M1 (2021) — $749
The iMac is the whole desktop in a single 11.5mm-thin panel: a 4.5K Retina display, a 1080p webcam that's noticeably better than most laptops, a good six-speaker sound system, plus a color-matched Magic Keyboard and Magic Mouse in the box. There are no cables to route beyond one power cord, nothing to match, and nothing to configure — you unbox it and you're working. The trade-off is that the screen and the computer are one unit: you can't upgrade the display independently, and you can't reuse it as a standalone monitor later.
- ✓ $749 — and that price includes a 4.5K screen, keyboard, and mouse
- ✓ Gorgeous 24" 4.5K Retina display, sharp 1080p webcam, great speakers
- ✓ One power cable — the cleanest desk in computing
- ✓ Comes in colors; keyboard and mouse are color-matched
- ✗ Screen and computer are one unit — no independent display upgrade
iMac 24" M3 (2023) — from $999
The M3 iMac is the same beautiful design with a newer, faster chip — worth it if you want the most future-proof all-in-one and the latest color options. For everyday desktop work the M1 iMac is already more than enough; choose the M3 for the extra headroom and the newest silicon.
Side-by-Side
| Mac mini M2 | iMac 24" M1 | |
|---|---|---|
| Starting price | $897.99 | $749 |
| Display included? | No — bring your own | Yes — 4.5K Retina built in |
| Keyboard + mouse | Not included | Included (color-matched) |
| Webcam | No — add your own | 1080p built in |
| Best for | You already own a monitor | You want a clean all-in-one |
| Upgrade the screen later? | Yes — just swap monitors | No — it's one unit |
The Hidden Cost Most People Miss
The mini looks $150 cheaper than the iMac, but that's only true if you already own a monitor, keyboard, and mouse. If you'd have to buy a decent 4K monitor ($200–$350) plus a keyboard and mouse ($50–$100), the mini can end up costing more than the iMac — and you'd be assembling a screen that won't match Apple's 4.5K Retina panel. So the honest math is: have the accessories already → mini wins on price; starting from nothing → the iMac is often the better deal and looks far nicer.
Why Refurbished Makes Sense for a Desktop
A desktop Mac sits on a desk and rarely moves — which makes it the ideal candidate for buying refurbished. It doesn't take the daily bumps a laptop does, so a Luxury Certified refurbished desktop looks and runs like new for a fraction of Apple's price. Every unit is inspected, cleaned, iCloud-cleared, and backed by our 1-year whole-machine warranty and a 30-day money-back guarantee, at 25–40% below Apple. Free shipping, Affirm financing over $300, and we take your old or broken Mac in trade.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the Mac mini or iMac faster?
For everyday work they feel identical — they run the same Apple-silicon chips and the same macOS. A Mac mini M2 Pro pulls ahead for heavy video editing or code compiling, but for web, Office, photos, and light video the mini M2 and the iMac M1 perform the same.
Can I use my own monitor with a Mac mini?
Yes — that's the whole idea. The Mac mini has HDMI and Thunderbolt outputs and drives up to two external displays. Plug in any monitor you already own; nothing extra to buy.
Can I use the iMac as a monitor for another computer?
No. The 24" M-series iMac cannot be used as an external display (there's no Target Display Mode on Apple silicon). The screen only works with the iMac's own computer inside it.
Which is better for a home office?
If you want the cleanest possible desk with nothing to configure, the iMac — one cable, built-in webcam and speakers, ready out of the box. If you already have a monitor and want to spend the least, the Mac mini.
Do I need the M2 Pro mini or the M3 iMac?
Only if you have a demanding workload (long video edits, development, virtual machines) or want the newest silicon. For typical desktop use, the $897.99 mini M2 and the $749 iMac M1 are plenty.
What comes in the box with each?
The Mac mini is just the computer and a power cable — you supply the screen, keyboard, and mouse. The iMac includes the 4.5K display, a color-matched Magic Keyboard and Magic Mouse, and one power cable.
Still not sure? Shop all refurbished Macs or take the 60-second quiz — or call Rick at (740) 223-5530.
Related guides: iMac vs MacBook | Best refurbished iMac | How much RAM do I need?